Analyst's note: Absolutely must read. You will want to be sitting down for this as well. You have often heard that "time will tell" ... well, we have been told ...again and again. Concern over political correctness, on-going diversity programs, and blind adherence to the Counterinsurgency (COIN) "strategy" and associated training has produced a U.S. military now being led by far too many senior "pacifistic" people unwilling, untrained, and inexperienced to defeat even a disorganized illiterate adversary such as the Taliban in Afghanistan.
Such pacifists are more and more unwilling to close with and destroy our enemies. Rather they prefer to sacrifice the American Warrior. Only God can help us if our nation permits our military to continue down this path without re-education and total correct re-indoctrination of such "leaders" if we are forced to face a modern sophisticated enemy in future conflicts. Such useful idiots are embedded throughout our federal government from our White House, National Security Counsel, Department of State, Department of Defense, Homeland Security, etc. etc.
Political correctness and accepting strategy suggestions from the Muslim Brotherhood (think enemy) embedded in our federal government, to include our Department of Defense, simply doesn't work for America. Now we have a U.S. Army Colonel who is telling our "leaders" in our White House & Pentagon of the details related to this systemic problem.
The American people need to read his letter in its entirety. Please review the entire letter by clicking here. Semper Fidelis.
The letter from Colonel Harry Tunnell is making its rounds around the internet, but here are some choice and relevant excerpts. But first a short bio of Tunnell.
Tunnell had been gravely wounded in Iraq, where he led a battalion of paratroopers with the 173rd Airborne Brigade. In October 2003, his convoy was ambushed by insurgents near the city of Kirkuk.
Despite his emphasis on education, Tunnell had a dim view of the intellectual underpinnings of counterinsurgency theory. He didn’t think insurgencies were defeated by protecting villages and winning over residents through reconstruction and development projects. He believed that the top priority was to kill the bad guys.
By the time Tunnell took over the brigade, every other infantry commander preparing to go to Iraq or Afghanistan was using Gen. Petraeus’ COIN manual as his lodestar. But not Tunnell. He told his soldiers that their approach to security operations would be drawn from an Army manual that outlined counterguerrilla operations, which had long been superseded by Petraeus’ playbook. Instead of emphasizing the protection of civilians, it instructed commanders to “give priority to destroying the guerrilla forces.” He called his unit the “Destroyer Brigade” and ordered that its vehicles be painted with the motto SEARCH AND DESTROY.
The Colonel speaks generally on the conflict
“The willingness to combat an enemy cannot be turned on and off like a light switch. Leaders are willing to conduct operations at the tactical and operational levels of war to decisively defeat the enemy or they are not. Soldiers join the military today to protect the United States, yet they are told once in Afghanistan that we are fighting for the Afghan people– this is a rather mercenary outlook and ignores the fact that the United States was attacked on September 11, 2001. If we have an army led by people unwilling to defeat a disorganized illiterate adversary such as we face today, even after a despicable surprise attack on our nation, there is little hope that we can defeat a modern sophisticated enemy that we may face in the future.”
He addresses the COIN (Counterinsurgency) disaster in some detail
The COIN doctrine that does exist consists of musings from amateurs, contractors, plagiarized journal articles, etc. It is not professional and relevant because it does not reflect the studied body of best practice– the concepts it promotes, in fact, contribute to needless American casualties.
COIN has become such a restrictive dogma that it cannot be questioned; any professional discussion about its strenghts and weaknesses is discouraged. It has reached such a crisis that those who employ other Army doctrinal concepts do so at their own professional peril because they will be subject to censure for not adhering to COIN. This has created a dysfunctional and toxic leadership throughout our army which has resulted in poor organization, unrealistic training and indecisive battlefield performance.
And then tells the following, almost unbelievable, story
Worst of all COIN dogma has degraded our ability to properly, effectively and realistically train for combat. As the commander of 5/2 ID (SBCT) I was continually badgered not to conduct brigade maneuver live fire training before deploying because NTC leaders deemed that we were already “too lethal” of an organization. As a military historian I am simply not familiar with the concept of an infantry brigade being too lethal and thus denied live fire training.
He critiques the politically correct consequences of COIN
“A gross lack of concern for subordinates manifests in guidance that “zero” civilian casualties are acceptable and coalition soldiers may have to be killed rather than defend themselves against a potential threat and risk being wrong and possibly resulting in injury or death of civilians.”
Population-centric approaches to war have resulted in senior officers are almost pacifistic in their approach to war; while they may have a public persona that seems offensively spirited that is not the reality when they are issuing guidelines to subordinates.”
And then tells the truth about the barbarism of our Afghan allies.
It is unlikely that Afghan security forces will be able to conduct independent operations with any degree of reliability because of a lack of technical skills. For example they do not have the ability to maintain vehicle fleets very well– most Afghans simply cannot drive.
Afghan males are among the greatest misogynists in the world. The Burqa is not a Taliban invention; it is a Pashtun norm.
Afghan military units– particularly small outposts, are bastions of filth. Rudimentary latrine facilities such as slit trenches are absent, even “cat holes” are unheard of. Afghans will select a room, if they are in a compound and use it for a latrine. If they are in an outdoor outpost, they defecate without measures to burn or discard the excrement.
Aberrant sexual behavior is acceptable… There is an acceptance of pedophilia that is widespread and boys are sometimes kidnapped. Leaders have been known to sexually assault male subordinates– even if sexual activity between males is consensual, it has implications for good order and discipline, which is why in many armies fraternization is not allowed.
NCOs cannot perform basic leadership and supply accountability functions well because they are largely illiterate. NCOs cannot manage clothing records for their illiterate soldiers, they cannot maintain weapons and equipment accountability if they cannot read a serial number, they cannot read an operations order for a tactical mission.
And finally a statement from the Colonel that has much wider applications to our efforts in the Muslim world.
Finally, a main COIN assumption is that the population does not want what the Taliban have to offer. This is an unbelievably flawed assumption… it might be more correct to assess that the population does not like how the Taliban deliver.
Now that you’ve read through all that, here’s an excerpt from his less classified writing.
Military leaders must stay focused on the destruction of the enemy. It is virtually impossible to convince any committed terrorist who hates America to change his or her point of view—they simply must be attacked relentlessly. … It is appropriate for military units to develop goals that include appreciating local culture, improving quality of life for the populace, and promoting good governance whenever these concepts improve access to the enemy. However, if the pursuit of them does not advance one’s knowledge of threats and a unit’s capability to maintain the offensive, then they are of little practical value as tactical or operational objectives. Destruction of the enemy force must remain the most important step to defeating terrorists and insurgents.
Related articles:
Obama can NOT be left in same room with our U.S. national security
Obama's 'wedding' ring prior to Michelle: 'There is no god but Allah'
More Proof of the Fruit of Counterinsurgency Madness!
Are Our Elected American Representatives leading us to another 'Operation Frequent Wind'?
Ominous news Explained: U.S. troops murdered by those they are forced to trust
Enemy Laughs: Lt. Col. Matthew Dooley Fired for Criticizing Islam at Joint Forces Staff College
Libyan reports shred White House claim that Benghazi attack was spontaneous, driven by anti-Islam
Historic details of Islam & why we are now afraid, A 1400 Year Secret
Obama's Weakness Dishonors and Humiliates America
Will it be the 'Collapse of America' or the 'Republic Reclaimed' -- Stand Up & Decide
CJCS Gen. Dempsey: Does not want to be complicit in Israeli strike
Comprehensive List: Obama's Worst Executive Orders
American General 'Excuses' Murder of American Servicemen in Afghanistan due to 'Religious Stress'!
'Pipe Down': Now legal threats to currently active and retired military
General John R. Allen (USMC) ... yet another useful idiot for jihad
Destroying Our U.S. Military from Within
With All Due Respect, General Dempsey
The Biggest D.C. Spy Scandal You Haven?t Heard About (Part Two)
Secret genocide against American veterans
Coming 'Financial Armageddon'?
Top US military general in Afghanistan to discuss 'insider' attacks on troops
Report details lavish spending of Army general with Fort Bragg ties
Six United States Marines Murdered; Two Acts of Treachery; One Day in the True Afghanistan!
WW III: Muslim Brotherhood Infiltration and their 'Grand Jihad' against America
US Military Tactical Manuals Describe How to Control Domestic (That is You) Insurrection
Re-election plan for man known as Obama... revolutionary style
'Commander-in-Chief' targets U.S Military voters & Defense workers
'Auschwitz-Like Conditions': U.S. General Accused of Massive Afghan Cover-Up to Protect Obama
July 27, 2012 U.N.'s Arms Trade Treaty (ATT): Death by a thousand cuts
Part I: MILITARY INSIDER: President Obama -- 'By Any Means Necessary'
Afghan Treachery and Visionless Strategy Continue to Kill American War Fighters!
Announcing Yet Another National Security Scandal with Barack Obama & Attorney Eric Holder
Dialog: East Coast - West Coast ... Winds of Revolution
Allen West to Obama: Why release a terrorist but not U.S. soldiers like Michael Behenna?
High Level Insider Alert: DHS Expects and Preparing for Another U.S. Civil War
Resettlement Camps: May Be Setup As 'DOMESTIC Civil Support Operations'
The Fog of War and Poor Battlefield Judgment
Dialog: East Coast - West Coast .. America's 'Useful Idiots'
U.S. IS TARGETED FROM WITHIN: World War III is Not a Rumor
Losing the jihadists' war on America: lslamist propaganda is slowly blinding us to the enemy within
JCS Dempsey: Afghans Must Prevent 'Green-on-Blue' Violence
